Read all about it – Gove makes a sensible decision!

Michael Gove appears to have finally made a decision that makes sense. This is the announcement that Ofsted should not inspect Free Schools for two years. There is much merit in this, since it takes that long to get a new school up and running.

I have had a fair amount of engagement with Free Schools; I have given advice prior to opening, I have helped schools to prepare for inspection and I have inspected them. The one characteristic shared by many of these schools is that they are simply not yet ready to be put through the fine mesh filter of Ofsted’s common inspection framework. For this reason the Secretary of State’s decision is a sensible one for once.

But, of course, it’s not as simple as that – as always there is the ideological neo-con gloss that robs the decision of its altruism. For each of the Free Schools will have received a pre-inspection visit from a DfE Adviser and, like Saladin’s messengers, they have told the Sultan what he wanted to hear. So these reports are full of phrases like ‘achievement is excellent’ and ‘teaching is outstanding’ while the reality is that, seen through Ofsted’s lens, it is often the case that neither of these is true. Therefore Mr Gove’s withdrawal of the Ofsted whip is clearly not to protect the schools but to protect himself from the criticism that is bound to follow when the Daily Mail headlines failing free schools.

Our colleagues who work in and run free schools are united in a zeal to make their schools the showcases of excellence that the DfE wishes them to be but it takes a while to set up the robust systems for pupil tracking and monitoring of teaching that will enable the dream to be realised. Dreams are one thing; hard data is another. It would be a mistake, at this stage, to remove Ofsted from the frame entirely; these new schools need – and would welcome – a monitoring visit. They do not welcome a full inspection that reveals weaknesses they are mostly aware of but have not yet had time to address. And Ofsted is not the DfE, it owes no allegiance to Saladin.

Whether Mr Gove understand the big picture remains to be seen. There is much wrong about this ideological Free Schools adventure but he cannot now leave them to face the future alone. Next time Education Monkey will swing around the business of funding Free Schools and Academies. It may not be comfortable reading.